Hilltop Bagel Cafe – Brookhaven, NY: Hours, Menu & Directions

Opening hours

Eastern Time

Opening hours have not been published for this bakery yet. Call (631) 846-1828 to check today's hours. Know the hours? Send them to us.

Tap for directions

623 Horseblock Road, Brookhaven, NY 11738

Google Maps Apple Maps Waze Bing Maps

Address623 Horseblock Road, Brookhaven, NY 11738

Phone(631) 846-1828

StyleBagel shop

CountySuffolk County

Time zoneEastern Time

From city center0.9 mi northwest

About Hilltop Bagel Cafe

Hilltop Bagel Cafe is a bagel shop at 623 Horseblock Road, roughly 0.9 mi from downtown Brookhaven, heading northwest. Besides being a bagel shop, it is also listed as bakery café.

Brookhaven has 25 places on our map that bake or sell fresh pastry, and this is one of them, which works out to one bakery per 19,710 residents. Nearest alternative: The Bread Palace Bakery & Cafe at 750 Horseblock Rd, 0.4 mi away.

We have not been able to confirm a full weekly schedule for Hilltop Bagel Cafe yet, so calling ahead at (631) 846-1828 is the safest bet. Bakeries often sell out of popular items by early afternoon.

At a glance

Listed as	Bagel shop and Bakery café
Bakeries in Brookhaven	25
Nearest bakery	0.4 mi

Suggest an edit

What to order

Typical items at a bagel shop like this one — the bakery's own selection may differ.

Full menu

Classic bagels

Cinnamon raisin bagelSwirled with cinnamon and plump raisins, lightly sweet and aromatic; best toasted with butter or plain cream cheese.
Pumpernickel bagelDark, rye-based bagel deepened with molasses, offering an earthy, slightly sour flavor and a tight, chewy crumb.
Egg bagelGolden-yellow bagel enriched with eggs for a softer, richer crumb and a faintly sweet, brioche-like flavor.
Plain bagelBoiled-then-baked ring with a shiny, blistered crust and dense, chewy interior; a clean base for any spread or sandwich.

Specialty bagels

Blueberry bagelPurple-tinted dough studded with dried blueberries, sweet and fruity; usually paired with honey or strawberry cream cheese.
French toast bagelSweet bagel brushed with cinnamon sugar and a touch of maple flavor, tasting like diner French toast in ring form.
Asiago bagelBaked under a crust of shredded Asiago cheese that crisps into lacy, sharp-tasting edges around the chewy ring.
Jalapeño cheddar bagelDough folded with diced jalapeños and baked under melted cheddar, bringing mild heat and salty, tangy cheese.

Cream cheese & spreads

Plain cream cheeseThick layer of whipped cream cheese; cool, tangy and the standard topping for a bagel fresh from the oven.
Scallion cream cheeseCream cheese mixed with plenty of chopped green onion for a mild, fresh oniony bite and flecks of color.
Lox spreadWhipped cream cheese blended with chopped smoked salmon, giving a salty, smoky spread without a full lox sandwich.
Vegetable cream cheeseCream cheese folded with finely diced carrot, celery, bell pepper and radish for crunch and a garden-fresh taste.

Photos

All photos

Hilltop Bagel Cafe in Brookhaven, NY — Hilltop Bagel Cafe

Food for sale on the counter of Jacob's Bakery + Cafe 2025-10-08 — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

Display case in a Chinese bakery — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

Cake display cases with cakes and pastries in Brastads Bageri 4 — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

Visitor reviews

Write a review

No reviews yet. Been to Hilltop Bagel Cafe? Your review helps other people decide — be the first to write one.

Questions about Hilltop Bagel Cafe

What are Hilltop Bagel Cafe's hours?

We have not verified a weekly schedule for Hilltop Bagel Cafe yet. Call (631) 846-1828 to confirm before visiting.

Where is Hilltop Bagel Cafe located?

Hilltop Bagel Cafe is at 623 Horseblock Road, Brookhaven, NY 11738. Tap the map on this page to open turn-by-turn directions.

What is the phone number for Hilltop Bagel Cafe?

The listed phone number is (631) 846-1828.

What should I order at Hilltop Bagel Cafe?

As a bagel shop, typical picks include Cinnamon raisin bagel, Pumpernickel bagel, Blueberry bagel, and French toast bagel. See the full menu page for more.

What other bakeries are near Hilltop Bagel Cafe?

Nearby options include The Bread Palace Bakery & Cafe (0.4 mi), Cupcake Girlz (0.4 mi), and Euro Fresh Bakery (0.7 mi).